I’m logging this day for the record and posterity.
Using the Nazi analogy to discredit political opponents is a popular game that seems to work best as a substitute for honest criticism. Although such comparisons usually do little more than expose one’s ignorance of the actual history of the Third Reich, it doesn’t mean that valid comparisons don’t exist. Within the right context, similarities can be drawn, Godwin’s Law be damned.
Actually, there’s only one good reason why the subject should ever be brought up in the first place. Nazi Germany was a fundamental transformation of a parliamentary democracy that became a one party dictatorship. Just as important, it was done within the government’s legal framework and with a popular mandate from the people. That factor alone makes it a relevant example of a government gone wrong—a compelling schematic and a warning for citizens concerned about the future of their own respective countries.
Those who live in states with the ballot initiative option will understand.
I like some of Neil Young’s music but he really is FOS. In a meandering, semi-coherent interview with Howard Stern, he said that al-Qaeda presents no danger compared to climate change because the carbon footprint left by terrorists is minuscule compared to that left by US military action. Neil Young might be better served by examining his own carbon footprint created by touring the country.